Map reviews: Difference between revisions
m Removed second title |
Fixed a lot more errors... |
||
| Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
===Looks=== | ===Looks=== | ||
That map looks (don't be fooled by the minimap!) really good. The central island is | That map looks (don't be fooled by the minimap!) really good. The central island is especially nice; the texture used is perfect. It is slightly stylized (like TA maps) not a real world... The metal around the edge actually looks pretty damn good too, as you don't notice the sea join at all. It gives it the feel of being on an island, without being on one. Other maps that come to the edge look bad because it seems abrupt. This avoids that problem because it's meant to be. | ||
One gripe that stops this from getting 9/10 | One gripe that stops this from getting 9/10: there are ramps, and they are necessary, but they spoil the look. However it's still is very good. | ||
8/10 | 8/10 | ||
| Line 18: | Line 18: | ||
===Playability=== | ===Playability=== | ||
The start positions are wrong. This is annoying. Also everyone will need to make them the same to play. | The start positions are wrong. This is annoying. Also everyone will need to make them the same to play. | ||
However it clearly has lots of potential for a good game once started. All the players would have to fight around and destroy there neighbours on land, and use air and sea to get the others, which could lead to all sorts of cool suprise attacks and so forth. | However it clearly has lots of potential for a good game once started. All the players would have to fight around and destroy there neighbours on land, and use air and sea to get the others, which could lead to all sorts of cool suprise attacks and so forth. The island in the middle, containing extra metal and great radar coverage, is a good place to get. | ||
Only one real problem: there is not much room for a base around the outside. If you started there, you'd be at a | Only one real problem: there is not much room for a base around the outside. If you started there, you'd be at a disadvantage. | ||
7/10 | 7/10 | ||
Want the map | Want the map? Get It here: [http://www.fileuniverse.com/?page=showitem&ID=1032 ] | ||
---- | ---- | ||
| Line 32: | Line 32: | ||
=== Looks === | === Looks === | ||
The map looks at first sight | The map looks, at first sight, pretty good. The texture is maybe a little repetitive, but it's different. The ambiance is good (i.e. sky effects and lighting). In "normal mode" it all looks fine! Just nothing special... | ||
However... The metal map is like somthing out of a funky light show. It's just green dots on the ground! They obviously meant to represent metal patches | However... The metal map is like somthing out of a funky light show. It's just green dots on the ground! They obviously meant to represent metal patches, but the time was not taken to add then onto the surface map. If they would have, I would forgive them but as they are--well they do look a bit off. | ||
7/10 | 7/10 | ||
=== Playability === | === Playability === | ||
Here it scores above average... | Here it scores above average... It's a simple concept, everything works well (as you'd hope in a second version...) No problems, except how easy it is to defend... Should 2 popup turrets and 4 imolators really be able to take down 100 mavericks? Not really... However the terrain does give that sort of great advantage to the defender; but a good attacker will be able to work around this! | ||
Its biggest problem here is just size... It's tiny really. Had it been a little bigger I'd have said 8/10, but it has dropped to 6/10. | |||
Want the map | Want the map? Get It here: | ||
http://www.fileuniverse.com/?page=showitem&ID=1011 | http://www.fileuniverse.com/?page=showitem&ID=1011 | ||
---- | ---- | ||
Revision as of 07:49, 23 June 2005
Anybody please feel free to add reviews to this section, or add to existing ones - latest reviews first.
If you don't understand how to edit this PM aGorm!
Bionica v3.1 (FINAL)
by aGorm
Looks
That map looks (don't be fooled by the minimap!) really good. The central island is especially nice; the texture used is perfect. It is slightly stylized (like TA maps) not a real world... The metal around the edge actually looks pretty damn good too, as you don't notice the sea join at all. It gives it the feel of being on an island, without being on one. Other maps that come to the edge look bad because it seems abrupt. This avoids that problem because it's meant to be. One gripe that stops this from getting 9/10: there are ramps, and they are necessary, but they spoil the look. However it's still is very good.
8/10
Playability
The start positions are wrong. This is annoying. Also everyone will need to make them the same to play. However it clearly has lots of potential for a good game once started. All the players would have to fight around and destroy there neighbours on land, and use air and sea to get the others, which could lead to all sorts of cool suprise attacks and so forth. The island in the middle, containing extra metal and great radar coverage, is a good place to get. Only one real problem: there is not much room for a base around the outside. If you started there, you'd be at a disadvantage.
7/10
Want the map? Get It here: [1]
Lava Highground 2 - v1.0
by aGorm
Looks
The map looks, at first sight, pretty good. The texture is maybe a little repetitive, but it's different. The ambiance is good (i.e. sky effects and lighting). In "normal mode" it all looks fine! Just nothing special...
However... The metal map is like somthing out of a funky light show. It's just green dots on the ground! They obviously meant to represent metal patches, but the time was not taken to add then onto the surface map. If they would have, I would forgive them but as they are--well they do look a bit off.
7/10
Playability
Here it scores above average... It's a simple concept, everything works well (as you'd hope in a second version...) No problems, except how easy it is to defend... Should 2 popup turrets and 4 imolators really be able to take down 100 mavericks? Not really... However the terrain does give that sort of great advantage to the defender; but a good attacker will be able to work around this!
Its biggest problem here is just size... It's tiny really. Had it been a little bigger I'd have said 8/10, but it has dropped to 6/10.
Want the map? Get It here: http://www.fileuniverse.com/?page=showitem&ID=1011
